Fox Boss Reportedly Thought X-Men Was A Disaster: "Why Would Anybody Make A Marvel Comic Into A Movie?”

Fox Boss Reportedly Thought X-Men Was A Disaster: "Why Would Anybody Make A Marvel Comic Into A Movie?”

The first X-Men movie kick-started one of 20th Century Fox's most successful franchises, but Rupert Murdoch was certain it would be a box office disaster...

By MarkCassidy - Apr 22, 2026 02:04 PM EST
Filed Under: X-Men
Source: Business Insider

Though the movies varied in quality, the X-Men franchise proved to be incredibly lucrative for 20th Century Fox, with Bryan Singer's original film spawning a number of sequels and spin-offs.

The film series went on to become one of the studio's biggest box office successes, but it's now come to light that the franchise could have been scrapped before it even got started if Rupert Murdoch had his way.

While speaking to Business Insider about the upcoming 4K re-release of David Fincher’s Fight Club, former CEO of Fox Filmed Entertainment, Bill Mechanic, revealed that Murdoch - whose News Corps. owned the studio at the time - and his fellow higher-ups were convinced that X-Men would be a "trainwreck."

“They saw it and thought it was a disaster — why would anybody make a Marvel comic into a movie?”

Even though Blade does also deserve credit, 2000's X-Men is widely regarded as the film that reinvigorated audience interest in the superhero genre after Batman and Robin was thought to have driven the final nail into the coffin. Sam Raimi's Spider-Man followed, and Marvel Studios' Iron Man launched the most successful movie franchise of all time in 2008.

Mechanic also revealed that Murdoch hated Fight Club, which, to be fair, was a notorious box office bomb upon its release. 

Here's an excerpt from Variety's report.

"If Murdoch didn’t want to be challenged, then there was no way he was going to like Fincher’s Fight Club. Based on Chuck Palahniuk’s novel and starring Brad Pitt and Edward Norton, Fincher’s brooding and violent vision allegedly outraged Murdoch. Mechanic remembered attending one News Corps. meeting where '[Rupert] started attacking, and he said, ‘What kind of sick [frick]ing human being would make a movie like this?’ I said, ‘Me. David Fincher. We’re not embarrassed.'”

“I knew he hadn’t seen the movie yet,” Mechanic added. “That’s probably the nexus of when he wanted to get rid of me.”

A lot of the original X-Men cast members are set to reprise their roles for Avengers: Doomsday, and we will meet a brand-new team in Marvel Studios' long-awaited reboot after Secret Wars.

They are children of the atom, homo superior, the next link in the chain of evolution. Each was born with a unique genetic mutation, which at puberty manifested itself in extraordinary powers. In a world filled with hate and prejudice, they are feared by those who cannot accept their differences. Led by Xavier the X-Men fight to protect a world that fears them. They are locked in a battle with former colleague and friend, Magneto who believes humans and mutants should never co-exist.

About The Author:
MarkCassidy
Member Since 11/9/2008
Mark Cassidy is a writer, photographer, amateur filmmaker, and Rotten Tomatoes-approved critic from Dublin, Ireland.
X-Men Reboot Rumored To Revolve Around These Mutants As Marvel Plans Big Change To Avengers Franchise
Related:

X-Men Reboot Rumored To Revolve Around These Mutants As Marvel Plans Big Change To Avengers Franchise

X-Men: Sydney Sweeney Rumored To Be On Marvel's Radar For MCU's Emma Frost
Recommended For You:

X-Men: Sydney Sweeney Rumored To Be On Marvel's Radar For MCU's Emma Frost

DISCLAIMER: As a user generated site and platform, Comic Book Movie is protected under the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) and "Safe Harbor" provisions.

This post was submitted by a user who has agreed to our Terms of Service and Community Guidelines. Comic Book Movie will disable users who knowingly commit plagiarism, piracy, trademark or copyright infringement. Please CONTACT US for expeditious removal of copyrighted/trademarked content. CLICK HERE to learn more about our copyright and trademark policies.

Note that Comic Book Movie, and/or the user who contributed this post, may earn commissions or revenue through clicks or purchases made through any third-party links contained within the content above.

MCUKnight11
MCUKnight11 - 4/22/2026, 2:21 PM
The actual disaster was how cyclops and rogue were handled.
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 4/22/2026, 2:26 PM
@MCUKnight11 - yep , agreed

Honestly , you could say that about pretty much anyone not named Wolverine , Xavier & Magneto (maybe even Jean) in those films.
TheVisionary25
TheVisionary25 - 4/22/2026, 2:25 PM
Ahh , another story of an exec being a shortsighted idiot.

In other news…

User Comment Image
Thing94
Thing94 - 4/22/2026, 2:43 PM
Wow he had some great insight into the film world I see lol
TheRationalNerd
TheRationalNerd - 4/22/2026, 2:50 PM
Clayface teaser is out!
Lokiwasright
Lokiwasright - 4/22/2026, 3:54 PM
@TheRationalNerd - who?
TheRationalNerd
TheRationalNerd - 4/22/2026, 4:42 PM
@Lokiwasright - Clayface
InfinitePunches
InfinitePunches - 4/22/2026, 3:01 PM
Saying this in a world where Batman and Superman have four blockbuster films each is actually hilarious.

"Sure, I get making DC movies. But Marvel? Really? Can't we make a Wonder Woman film or something?"
DENNISsystem
DENNISsystem - 4/22/2026, 3:34 PM
Rupert Murdoch has always been an ass. Simpsons have been saying it since the early 90’s
Lokiwasright
Lokiwasright - 4/22/2026, 3:51 PM
They were all talking shit about comicbook films in the 90s. They all thought it would be a bad idea.

Now only comicbook film, video game films are dominating theatres.
dragon316
dragon316 - 4/22/2026, 4:11 PM
@Lokiwasright - yes and no depends on movie and main movie is focus on fantastic four barley made profit while Superman is more popular than fantastic four comics and entertainment same with Batman and Spider-Man Deadpool
EscapeMySight
EscapeMySight - 4/22/2026, 4:26 PM
Well Tom Rothman is a [frick]ing moron, so I'm not very surprised.
tvor03
tvor03 - 4/22/2026, 4:41 PM
Blade wasn't seen as a superhero movie by the general audience. To them, it was a vampire/action movie. So XMen really was the film to kick off the trend of superhero movies, that is now 26 years and counting.
DrCigarettes
DrCigarettes - 4/22/2026, 5:11 PM
That would be because Zionists like Rupert Murdoch are out of touch with reality and dumb. They live in their own reality where they think they are always right.

He’s a vile human whose outlets were involved in the hacking of the mobile phones of two murdered young girls in the UK. He knew full well what was going on.

Rupert Murdoch is a nasty, ruthless evil piece of S H I T.

Only dirty Zionist rats appreciate him.

Please log in to post comments.

Don't have an account?
Please Register.

View Recorder